Value pick · Our pick
Half-pound cookies
One cookie is plenty for two.
Dish source: DFBGuideDisney Springs
Restaurant hours when sourced; otherwise the park day is clearly labelled.
Value pick · Our pick
One cookie is plenty for two.
Dish source: DFBGuide ↗Picky-eater pick · Our pick
A big cookie.
Dish source: DFBGuide ↗Official dish names are grouped by meal period. Creator reports are dated evidence, not a promise that an item is still served.
34 dishes reported
Allergens not stated — ask the chef. “Unknown” never means safe.
Official menu ↗ · as of Oct 19, 2026
Allergens not stated — ask the chef. “Unknown” never means safe.
Official menu ↗ · as of Oct 19, 2026
Allergens not stated — ask the chef. “Unknown” never means safe.
Official menu ↗ · as of Oct 19, 2026
Allergens not stated — ask the chef. “Unknown” never means safe.
Official menu ↗ · as of Oct 19, 2026
Allergens not stated — ask the chef. “Unknown” never means safe.
Official menu ↗ · as of Oct 19, 2026
Monthly specialty iced coffee at Gideon's; good but too sugary, still second to the nutty PB flavour.
Allergens not stated — ask the chef. “Unknown” never means safe.
Official menu ↗ · as of Oct 19, 2026
Reports: WrightDownMainStreet, Oct 21, 2023 ↗
Allergens not stated — ask the chef. “Unknown” never means safe.
Official menu ↗ · as of Oct 19, 2026
Allergens not stated — ask the chef. “Unknown” never means safe.
Official menu ↗ · as of Oct 19, 2026
Allergens not stated — ask the chef. “Unknown” never means safe.
Official menu ↗ · as of Oct 19, 2026
Allergens not stated — ask the chef. “Unknown” never means safe.
Official menu ↗ · as of Oct 19, 2026
Allergens not stated — ask the chef. “Unknown” never means safe.
Official menu ↗ · as of Oct 19, 2026
Allergens not stated — ask the chef. “Unknown” never means safe.
Official menu ↗ · as of Oct 19, 2026
Thick gooey dough-centred cookie loaded with chips plus flaky salt; ranked first overall, a must for newcomers.
Allergens not stated — ask the chef. “Unknown” never means safe.
Official menu ↗ · as of Oct 19, 2026
Reports: WrightDownMainStreet, Apr 6, 2026 ↗
Allergens not stated — ask the chef. “Unknown” never means safe.
Official menu ↗ · as of Oct 19, 2026
Allergens not stated — ask the chef. “Unknown” never means safe.
Official menu ↗ · as of Oct 19, 2026
Allergens not stated — ask the chef. “Unknown” never means safe.
Official menu ↗ · as of Oct 19, 2026
Allergens not stated — ask the chef. “Unknown” never means safe.
Official menu ↗ · as of Oct 19, 2026
Allergens not stated — ask the chef. “Unknown” never means safe.
Official menu ↗ · as of Oct 19, 2026
Allergens not stated — ask the chef. “Unknown” never means safe.
Official menu ↗ · as of Oct 19, 2026
Gooey toffee banana cookie with wafer crunch and salt, like two Gideon favourites combined; top seasonal.
Allergens not stated — ask the chef. “Unknown” never means safe.
Reports: WrightDownMainStreet, Jan 22, 2026 ↗
Real banana taste with walnuts, chocolate and a salt sprinkle; she names it her favourite cookie ever.
Allergens not stated — ask the chef. “Unknown” never means safe.
Reports: WrightDownMainStreet, Jan 6, 2024 ↗
Monthly cold brew with house banana syrup, muffin-like and balanced; on par with the PB version.
Allergens not stated — ask the chef. “Unknown” never means safe.
Reports: WrightDownMainStreet, Jan 22, 2026 ↗
Thick Oreo-studded cookie she rarely orders; better than she remembered, though the classic still wins.
Allergens not stated — ask the chef. “Unknown” never means safe.
Reports: WrightDownMainStreet, Jan 6, 2024 ↗
October cocoa cookie loaded with Oreos and full-size M&Ms; tasty but ordinary, chunky candy a chore.
Allergens not stated — ask the chef. “Unknown” never means safe.
Reports: WrightDownMainStreet, Oct 21, 2023 ↗
Moist slice with thick cookie-flecked frosting that is not cloying; among her favourite Gideon's flavours.
Allergens not stated — ask the chef. “Unknown” never means safe.
Reports: WrightDownMainStreet, Jan 6, 2024 ↗
Allergens not stated — ask the chef. “Unknown” never means safe.
Reports: DFBGuide ↗
Rich cookie with lime and pie-crust crumbs; among her favourite monthly flavours ever.
Allergens not stated — ask the chef. “Unknown” never means safe.
Reports: WrightDownMainStreet, Jul 8, 2023 ↗
Tart curd, lots of whipped topping and graham base; tasty, though she prefers the bakery's cakes and cookies.
Allergens not stated — ask the chef. “Unknown” never means safe.
Reports: WrightDownMainStreet, Jun 28, 2025 ↗
Rare cake slice with tart frosting, milder sponge and graham crumble centre; perfectly balanced.
Allergens not stated — ask the chef. “Unknown” never means safe.
Reports: WrightDownMainStreet, Feb 13, 2024 ↗
Odd coffee and lemonade combo reminiscent of a citrus sugar biscuit; interesting, but too sugary for more than sips.
Allergens not stated — ask the chef. “Unknown” never means safe.
Reports: WrightDownMainStreet, Jun 28, 2025 ↗
Seasonal monthly cookie named a personal favorite.
Allergens not stated — ask the chef. “Unknown” never means safe.
Reports: DFBGuide, Sep 21, 2026 ↗
Strongly peanutty cookie reminiscent of a candy cup; coffee taste barely registers.
Allergens not stated — ask the chef. “Unknown” never means safe.
Reports: Coffee Before Coasters, Aug 7, 2026 ↗ · WrightDownMainStreet, May 2, 2024 ↗
Half-pound gooey-centred classic loaded with chips and salt flakes; she calls it the perfect version, unbeatable.
Allergens not stated — ask the chef. “Unknown” never means safe.
Reports: WrightDownMainStreet, Jan 6, 2024 ↗
New February cookie with dark chocolate and real-tasting berry sugar; among the bakery's best specials.
Allergens not stated — ask the chef. “Unknown” never means safe.
Reports: WrightDownMainStreet, Feb 13, 2024 ↗