Old Key West Resort
Olivia's Cafe
Hours and menu date
Restaurant hours when sourced; otherwise the park day is clearly labelled.
Menu and creator reports
Official dish names are grouped by meal period. Creator reports are dated evidence, not a promise that an item is still served.
17 dishes reported
For allergy questions, ask for a Special Diets-trained Cast Member. Disney kitchens are not allergen-free. A dated “reported adjustable” claim appears only when a source states one.
Creator reports
Banana bread French toast
Mom's favourite: moist banana loaf slices with rum syrup and crisp tops; super rich, best shared.
Price history
- $19.00 observed Jan 26, 2025 · WrightDownMainStreet at 9:41 ↗
Allergens not stated — ask the chef. “Unknown” never means safe.
Reports: WrightDownMainStreet, Jan 26, 2025 ↗
Banana bread pudding
Moist muffin-style pudding under a Foster-style banana glaze; delicious though too sugary for her to finish.
Allergens not stated — ask the chef. “Unknown” never means safe.
Reports: WrightDownMainStreet, May 22, 2023 ↗
Biscuit
Flaky layered side biscuit, slightly dry yet clearly made fresh rather than packaged.
Allergens not stated — ask the chef. “Unknown” never means safe.
Reports: WrightDownMainStreet, May 22, 2023 ↗
Buttermilk biscuit
Flaky, moist biscuit with Cajun-ish dusting and whipped butter; far from the usual dry kind.
Allergens not stated — ask the chef. “Unknown” never means safe.
Reports: WrightDownMainStreet, Jan 26, 2025 ↗
Conch fritters
Moist, mildly spicy fritters elevated by tangy citrus mustard dip; outshone the cornmeal puppies.
Price history
- $15.00 observed Jan 26, 2025 · WrightDownMainStreet at 18:20 ↗
Allergens not stated — ask the chef. “Unknown” never means safe.
Reports: WrightDownMainStreet, Jan 26, 2025 ↗
Key lime pie
Finger-sized sliver baked next door at the neighbouring resort; tart and creamy but laughably small for nine dollars.
Price history
- $9.00 observed Jan 26, 2025 · WrightDownMainStreet at 26:33 ↗
Allergens not stated — ask the chef. “Unknown” never means safe.
Reports: WrightDownMainStreet, Jan 26, 2025 ↗
Mahi mahi
Well-seasoned fish with succotash and chorizo butter, slightly overcooked, corn silk seemingly missing.
Price history
- $33.00 observed Jan 26, 2025 · WrightDownMainStreet at 22:53 ↗
Allergens not stated — ask the chef. “Unknown” never means safe.
Reports: WrightDownMainStreet, Jan 26, 2025 ↗
Oatmeal brulee
Torched-sugar oatmeal starter; she admits oatmeal never works for her, mostly a texture issue.
Allergens not stated — ask the chef. “Unknown” never means safe.
Reports: WrightDownMainStreet, May 22, 2023 ↗
Olivia's breakfast potatoes
Gravy-laced, cheese-baked spuds she ranks among Disney's finest morning sides, admittedly indulgent.
Allergens not stated — ask the chef. “Unknown” never means safe.
Reports: WrightDownMainStreet, Jan 26, 2025 ↗
Olivia's Eye Opener
Signature brunch cocktail, potent but tasty once the grenadine got stirred through.
Allergens not stated — ask the chef. “Unknown” never means safe.
Reports: WrightDownMainStreet, May 22, 2023 ↗
Savory hush puppies
Seven dense cornbread-like fritters, honeyed butter alongside; tasty yet heavy and not special enough to reorder.
Price history
- $12.00 observed Jan 26, 2025 · WrightDownMainStreet at 16:56 ↗
Allergens not stated — ask the chef. “Unknown” never means safe.
Reports: WrightDownMainStreet, Jan 26, 2025 ↗
Shrimp fritters
Fried shrimp bites compared to hush puppies and cheesy biscuits; standout of the brunch.
Allergens not stated — ask the chef. “Unknown” never means safe.
Reports: WrightDownMainStreet, May 22, 2023 ↗
Sombrero Beach omelette
Ham, peppers, onion and cheddar folded, topped with crema plus salsa; plain but dependable, wants more seasoning.
Price history
- $17.00 observed Jan 26, 2025 · WrightDownMainStreet at 6:59 ↗
Allergens not stated — ask the chef. “Unknown” never means safe.
Reports: WrightDownMainStreet, Jan 26, 2025 ↗
Southernmost buttermilk chicken
Juicy boneless crispy breast with mash, veggies and biscuit; superb with leftover lime mustard, a bargain.
Price history
- $26.00 observed Jan 26, 2025 · WrightDownMainStreet at 24:04 ↗
Allergens not stated — ask the chef. “Unknown” never means safe.
Reports: WrightDownMainStreet, Jan 26, 2025 ↗
Southernmost buttermilk fried chicken
Signature crunchy chicken on mash, smothered in gravy; she calls it a must-order.
Allergens not stated — ask the chef. “Unknown” never means safe.
Reports: WrightDownMainStreet, May 22, 2023 ↗
Sweet bread loaf with whipped butter
Warm complimentary loaf identical to the Polynesian breakfast bread; generic now but she always enjoys it.
Allergens not stated — ask the chef. “Unknown” never means safe.
Reports: WrightDownMainStreet, Jan 26, 2025 ↗
Tropical fruit with acai pudding
Shareable fruit plate she liked, but the runny, barely sweet acai pudding was only okay.
Price history
- $14.00 observed Jan 26, 2025 · WrightDownMainStreet at 5:23 ↗
Allergens not stated — ask the chef. “Unknown” never means safe.
Reports: WrightDownMainStreet, Jan 26, 2025 ↗